test/Tools/isac/Test_Isac.thy
author Walther Neuper <wneuper@ist.tugraz.at>
Mon, 21 Nov 2016 12:47:02 +0100
changeset 59260 0161ef48c8cc
parent 59259 d1c13ee4e1a2
child 59261 61a1bcd51e0e
permissions -rwxr-xr-x
added structure Kernel: KERNEL

Note: the preliminary identifier Math_Engine conflicts with mathengine.sml
     1 (* Title:  All tests on isac (some outcommented since Isabelle2002-->2009-2)
     2    Author: Walther Neuper 101001
     3    (c) copyright due to license terms.
     4 
     5    Isac's tests are organised parallel to sources: 
     6      "~~/test/Tools/isac" has same directory structure as "~~/src/Tools/isac"
     7    plus
     8      ~~/test/Tools/isac/ADDTESTS
     9      ~~/test/Tools/isac/Minisubpbl: the Lucas-Interpreter's core functionality
    10 
    11 $ cd /usr/local/isabisac/
    12 $ ./bin/isabelle jedit -l Isac test/Tools/isac/Test_Isac.thy &
    13 *)
    14 
    15 section \<open>Prepare running tests\<close>
    16 text \<open>
    17 Isac encapsulates code as much as possible in structures without open. TODO
    18 This policy conflicts with those tests, which go into functions to details
    19 not declared in the signatures.
    20 
    21 In order to maintain these tests without changes, this has to be done before running tests:
    22 (1) Query replace in src/Tools/isac:
    23     "--- ! aktivate for Test_Isac BEGIN ---\* )" \<longrightarrow> "--- ! aktivate for Test_Isac BEGIN ---\*)"
    24     "( *\--- ! aktivate for Test_Isac END ---"   \<longrightarrow> "(*\--- ! aktivate for Test_Isac END ---"
    25   This extends the signatures with some functions required for some tests.
    26 
    27 Running Test_Isac.thy opens all structures, see code after "begin" below.
    28 
    29 *   before running Test_Isac.thy  ^^^            \<longrightarrow>  ^^^  in src/Tools/isac
    30 *   after running Test_Isac.thy   ^^^            <--  ^^^  in src/Tools/isac
    31 *********************** DON'T FORGET TO REVERSE CHANGE (1) AFTER TESTS ***********************
    32 \<close>
    33 
    34 section \<open>Run the tests\<close>
    35 text \<open>
    36 * say "OK" to the popup asking for theories to be loaded
    37 * watch the <Theories> window for errors in the "imports" below
    38 \<close>
    39 
    40 theory Test_Isac imports Build_Thydata
    41   "ADDTESTS/accumulate-val/Thy_All"
    42   "ADDTESTS/Ctxt"
    43   "ADDTESTS/test-depend/Build_Test"
    44   "ADDTESTS/All_Ctxt"
    45   "ADDTESTS/Test_Units"
    46   "ADDTESTS/course/phst11/T1_Basics"
    47   "ADDTESTS/course/phst11/T2_Rewriting"
    48   "ADDTESTS/course/phst11/T3_MathEngine"
    49   "ADDTESTS/file-depend/BuildC_Test"
    50   "ADDTESTS/session-get_theory/Foo"
    51 (*"ADDTESTS/course/SignalProcess/Build_Inverse_Z_Transform"
    52    ADDTESTS/------------------------------------------- see end of tests *)
    53 (*"~~/test/Pure/Isar/Test_Parsers"           dropped Isabelle2014-->2015 *)
    54 (*"~~/test/Pure/Isar/Pure/Isar/Struct_Deriv" lost at update 2009-2-->2011*)
    55   "~~/test/Pure/Isar/Test_Parse_Term"
    56   "~~/test/HOL/Library/Test_Polynomial"
    57   "~~/test/Tools/isac/Interpret/ptyps"       (* setup for ptyps.sml    *)
    58   "~~/test/Tools/isac/ProgLang/calculate"    (* setup for calculate.sml*)
    59   "~~/test/Tools/isac/ProgLang/scrtools"     (* setup for scrtools.sml *)
    60   "~~/test/Tools/isac/Knowledge/integrate"   (* setup for integrate.sml*)
    61 
    62   "~~/src/Tools/isac/Knowledge/GCD_Poly_OLD" (*not imported by Isac.thy*)
    63   "~~/src/Tools/isac/Knowledge/GCD_Poly_FP"  (*not imported by Isac.thy*)
    64 
    65 begin
    66 
    67 ML {*
    68 (*/-------------------------------------------------------- ! aktivate for Test_Isac BEGIN ---\*)
    69   open Lucin;
    70   open Kernel;
    71 (*\--- ! aktivate for Test_Isac END ----------------------------------------------------------/*)
    72 *}
    73 ML {*
    74   KEStore_Elems.set_ref_thy @{theory};
    75   (*fun autoCalculate' cI auto = autoCalculate cI auto (*|> Future.join*)*);
    76 *}
    77 
    78 section {* trials with Isabelle's functions *}
    79   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start Isabelle %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
    80   ML_file "~~/test/Pure/General/alist.ML"
    81   ML_file "~~/test/Pure/General/basics.ML"
    82   ML_file "~~/test/Pure/General/scan.ML"
    83   ML_file "~~/test/Pure/PIDE/xml.ML"
    84   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end Isabelle %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
    85 
    86 section {* test ML Code of isac *}
    87   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start ProgLang.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
    88   ML_file          "library.sml"
    89   ML_file          "calcelems.sml"
    90   ML_file          "kestore.sml"
    91   ML_file "ProgLang/termC.sml"
    92   ML_file "ProgLang/calculate.sml"      (* requires setup from calculate.thy *)
    93   ML_file "ProgLang/rewrite.sml"
    94   ML_file "ProgLang/listC.sml"
    95   ML_file "ProgLang/scrtools.sml"
    96   ML_file "ProgLang/tools.sml"
    97   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end ProgLang.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
    98   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start Minisubpbl %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
    99   ML_file "Minisubpbl/000-comments.sml"
   100   ML_file "Minisubpbl/100-init-rootpbl.sml"
   101   ML_file "Minisubpbl/150-add-given.sml"
   102   ML_file "Minisubpbl/200-start-method.sml"
   103   ML_file "Minisubpbl/300-init-subpbl.sml"
   104   ML_file "Minisubpbl/400-start-meth-subpbl.sml"
   105   ML_file "Minisubpbl/490-nxt-Check_Postcond.sml"
   106   ML_file "Minisubpbl/500-met-sub-to-root.sml"
   107   ML_file "Minisubpbl/530-error-Check_Elementwise.sml"
   108   ML_file "Minisubpbl/600-postcond.sml"
   109   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end Minisubpbl.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   110   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start Interpret.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   111   ML_file "Interpret/mstools.sml"
   112   ML_file "Interpret/ctree.sml"         (*!...!see(25)*)
   113   ML_file "Interpret/ptyps.sml"         (* requires setup from ptyps.thy *)
   114   ML {* (*check_unsynchronized_ref (); ==== trick on error: CUT AND PASTE THIS LINE =========*) *}
   115 (*TRICK DOESN'T WORK: get_pbt not found: ["IsacKnowledge","Diff","Theorems","diff_sin_chain"]*)
   116   ML_file "Interpret/generate.sml"
   117 (*WITHOUT inhibit exn WN1130621 Isabelle2012-->13 !thehier! THIS ERROR OCCURS:
   118   ... SAME ERROR HERE ON ISABELLE2012 AS IN ISAC ON ISABELLE2011*)
   119   ML_file "Interpret/calchead.sml"
   120   ML_file "Interpret/appl.sml"          (*complete "WEGEN INTERMED TESTCODE"   *)
   121   ML_file "Interpret/rewtools.sml"
   122   ML_file "Interpret/script.sml"
   123   ML_file "Interpret/solve.sml"
   124   ML_file "Interpret/inform.sml"
   125 (*WITHOUT inhibit exn WN1130621 Isabelle2012-->13 !thehier! THIS ERROR OCCURS:
   126   ... SAME ERROR HERE ON ISABELLE2012 AS IN ISAC ON ISABELLE2011*)
   127   ML_file "Interpret/mathengine.sml"    (*!part. WN130804: +check Interpret/me.sml*)
   128   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end Interpret.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   129   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start xmlsrc.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   130   ML_file "xmlsrc/mathml.sml"           (*part.*)
   131   ML_file "xmlsrc/datatypes.sml"        (*TODO/part.*)
   132   ML_file "xmlsrc/pbl-met-hierarchy.sml"(*TODO after 2009-2/part.*)
   133   ML_file "xmlsrc/thy-hierarchy.sml"
   134   ML_file "xmlsrc/interface-xml.sml"     (*TODO after 2009-2*)
   135   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end xmlsrc.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   136   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start Frontend.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   137   ML_file "Frontend/messages.sml"
   138   ML_file "Frontend/states.sml"
   139   ML_file "Frontend/interface.sml"
   140   ML_file "Frontend/use-cases.sml"
   141 (*WITHOUT inhibit exn WN1130621 Isabelle2012-->13 !thehier! THIS ERROR OCCURS:
   142   ... SAME ERROR HERE ON ISABELLE2012 AS IN ISAC ON ISABELLE2011*)
   143   ML_file          "print_exn_G.sml"
   144   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end Frontend.thy %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   145   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start Knowledge %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   146   ML_file "Knowledge/delete.sml"
   147   ML_file "Knowledge/descript.sml"
   148   ML_file "Knowledge/atools.sml"
   149   ML_file "Knowledge/simplify.sml"
   150   ML_file "Knowledge/poly.sml"
   151   ML_file "Knowledge/gcd_poly_ml.sml"
   152   ML_file "Knowledge/gcd_poly_winkler.sml" (*must be after gcd_poly_ml.sml: redefines functions*)
   153   ML_file "Knowledge/rational.sml"
   154   ML_file "Knowledge/equation.sml"
   155   ML_file "Knowledge/root.sml"
   156   ML_file "Knowledge/lineq.sml"
   157 (*ML_file "Knowledge/rooteq.sml"    some complicated equations not recovered from 2002 *)
   158   ML_file "Knowledge/rateq.sml"   (*some complicated equations not recovered from 2002 *)
   159   ML_file "Knowledge/rootrat.sml"
   160   ML_file "Knowledge/rootrateq.sml"(*ome complicated equations not recovered from 2002 *)
   161   ML_file "Knowledge/partial_fractions.sml"
   162   ML_file "Knowledge/polyeq.sml"
   163 (*ML_file "Knowledge/rlang.sml"     much to clean up, similar tests in other files     *)
   164   ML_file "Knowledge/calculus.sml"
   165   ML_file "Knowledge/trig.sml"
   166 (*ML_file "Knowledge/logexp.sml"    not included as stuff for presentation of authoring*) 
   167   ML_file "Knowledge/diff.sml"
   168   ML_file "Knowledge/integrate.sml"
   169   ML_file "Knowledge/eqsystem.sml"
   170   ML_file "Knowledge/test.sml"
   171   ML_file "Knowledge/polyminus.sml"
   172   ML_file "Knowledge/vect.sml"
   173   ML_file "Knowledge/diffapp.sml"        (* postponed to dev. specification | TP-prog. *)
   174   ML_file "Knowledge/biegelinie.sml"
   175   ML_file "Knowledge/algein.sml"
   176   ML_file "Knowledge/diophanteq.sml"
   177   ML_file "Knowledge/Inverse_Z_Transform/inverse_z_transform.sml"
   178   ML_file "Knowledge/inssort.sml"
   179   ML_file "Knowledge/isac.sml"
   180   ML_file "Knowledge/build_thydata.sml"
   181   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end Knowledge %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   182   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% start ADDTESTS %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   183   ML_file "~~/test/Tools/isac/ADDTESTS/libisabelle/mini-test.sml"
   184   ML_file "~~/test/Tools/isac/ADDTESTS/libisabelle/protocol.sml"
   185   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end ADDTESTS %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   186 
   187   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   188   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% end Test_Isac %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   189   ML {*"%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%";*}
   190 
   191 section {* history of tests *}
   192 text {*
   193   Systematic regression tests have been introduced to isac development in 2003.
   194   Sanity of the regression tests suffers from updates following Isabelle development,
   195   which mostly exceeded the resources available in isac's development.
   196 
   197   The survey below shall support to efficiently use the tests for isac 
   198   on different Isabelle versions. Conclusion in most cases will be: 
   199 
   200   !!! Use most recent tests or go back to the old notebook
   201       with isac on Isabelle2002. !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
   202 *}
   203 
   204 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2014 *}
   205 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   206 text {*
   207   migration from "isabelle tty" --> libisabelle
   208 *}
   209 
   210 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2013-2 *}
   211 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   212 text {*
   213   reactivated context_thy
   214 *}
   215 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   216 text {*
   217   TODO
   218 *}
   219 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   220 text {*
   221   TODO
   222   :
   223   : isac on Isablle2013-2
   224   :
   225   Changeset: 55318 (03826ceb24da) merged
   226   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   227   Date: 2013-12-12 14:27:37 +0100 (7 minutes)
   228 *}
   229 
   230 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2013-1 *}
   231 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   232 text {*
   233   Isabelle2013-1 was replaced within a few weeks due to problems with the document model;
   234   no significant development steps for ISAC.
   235 *}
   236 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   237 text {*
   238   See points in subsection "isac on Isabelle2011", "State of tests".
   239 *}
   240 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   241 text {*
   242   Changeset: 55283 (d6e9a34e7142) notes for resuming work on Polynomial.thy
   243   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   244   Date: 2013-12-03 18:13:31 +0100 (8 days)
   245   :
   246   : isac on Isablle2013-1
   247   :
   248   Changeset: 55279 (130688f277ba) Isabelle2013 --> 2013-1: Test_Isac perfect
   249   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   250   Date: 2013-11-21 18:12:17 +0100 (2 weeks)
   251 
   252 *}
   253 
   254 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2013 *}
   255 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   256 text {*
   257   # Oct.13: replaced "axioms" by "axiomatization"
   258   # Oct.13: Mathias Lehnfeld started removing Unsynchornized.ref
   259   # Sep.13: integrated gcd_poly (functional, without Unsychronized.ref) into
   260     simplification of multivariate rationals (without improving the rulesets involved).
   261 *}
   262 subsubsection {* Run tests *}
   263 text {*
   264   Is standard now; this subsection will be discontinued under Isabelle2013-1
   265 *}
   266 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   267 text {*
   268   See points in subsection "isac on Isabelle2011", "State of tests".
   269   # re-activated listC.sml
   270 *}
   271 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   272 text {*
   273   changeset 52174:8b055b17bd84 --- removed all code concerned with "castab = Unsynchronized.ref"
   274   User: Mathias Lehnfeld <s1210629013@students.fh-hagenberg.at>
   275   Date: Tue Nov 19 22:23:30 2013 +0000
   276   :
   277   : isac on Isablle2013 
   278   :
   279   Changeset: 52061 (4ecea2fcdc2c) --- Build_Isac.thy runs on Isabelle2013
   280   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   281   Date: 2013-07-15 08:28:50 +0200 (4 weeks)
   282 *}
   283 
   284 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2012 *}
   285 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   286 text {*
   287   isac on Isabelle2012 is considered just a transitional stage
   288   within the update from Isabelle2011 to Isabelle2013; thus no further development of isac;
   289   For considerations on the transition see 
   290   ~~/src/Tools/isac/Knowledge/Build_Thydata/thy, section "updating isac..".
   291 *}
   292 subsubsection {* Run tests *}
   293 text {*
   294 $ cd /usr/local/isabisac12/
   295 $ ./bin/isabelle jedit -l HOL src/Tools/isac/Build_Isac.thy
   296 $ ./bin/isabelle jedit -l Isac test/Tools/isac/Test_Isac.thy
   297 *}
   298 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   299 text {*
   300   At least the tests from isac on Isabelle2011 run again.
   301   However, Test_Isac.thy shows erratic behaviour; no errors are obtained when scrolling 
   302   in parallel with evaluation.
   303 
   304   Counting "error in kernel" for Frontend/interface.sml (the tests considered most significant)
   305   yields 69 hits, some of which were already present before Isabelle2002-->2009-2
   306   (i.e. on the old notebook from 2002).
   307 
   308   Now many tests with (*...=== inhibit exn ...*) give a reason or at least the origin:
   309   # === inhibit exn WN1130621 Isabelle2012-->13 !thehier! === ...see Build_Thydata.thy
   310   # === inhibit exn AK110726 === ...reliable work by Alexander Kargl, most likely go back to 2002
   311   # === inhibit exn WN1130701 broken at Isabelle2002 --> 2009-2 === , most likely go back to 2002
   312   Reasons for outcommented tests are also found in Test_Isac.thy near the respective file.sml.
   313 
   314   Some tests have been re-activated (e.g. error patterns, fill patterns).
   315 *}
   316 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   317 text {*  
   318   Changeset: 52051 (35751d90365e) end of improving tests for isac on Isabelle2012
   319   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   320   Date: 2013-07-11 16:58:31 +0200 (4 weeks)
   321   :
   322   : isac on Isablle2012 
   323   :
   324   Changeset: 48757 (74eb3dfc33cc) updated src from Isabelle2011 to Isabelle2012
   325   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   326   Date: 2012-09-24 18:35:13 +0200 (8 months)
   327   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   328   Changeset: 48756 (7443906996a8) merged
   329   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   330   Date: 2012-09-24 18:15:49 +0200 (8 months)
   331 *}
   332 
   333 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2011 *}
   334 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   335 text {*
   336   isac's mathematics engine has been extended by two developments:
   337   (1) Isabelle's contexts were introduced by Mathias Lehnfeld
   338   (2) Z_Transform was introduced by Jan Rocnik, which revealed
   339     further errors introduced by (1).
   340   (3) "error patterns" were introduced by Gabriella Daroczy
   341   Regressions tests have been added for all of these.
   342 *}
   343 subsubsection {* Run tests *}
   344 text {*
   345   $ cd /usr/local/isabisac11/
   346   $ ./bin/isabelle jedit -l HOL src/Tools/isac/Build_Isac.thy
   347   $ ./bin/isabelle jedit -l Isac test/Tools/isac/Test_Isac.thy
   348 *}
   349 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   350 text {* 
   351   Systematic efforts outcommented less significant tests by (*...=== inhibit exn ...*) 
   352   and sometimes give reasons for failing tests.
   353   (*...=== inhibit exn AK...*) was done by Alexander Kargl; this is reliable
   354   work, some of which couldn't be revised (and renamed) by WN and thus survived some time.
   355 
   356   The most signification tests (in particular Frontend/interface.sml) run,
   357   however, many "error in kernel" are not caught by an exception.
   358   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   359   After the changeset below Test_Isac worked with check_unsynchronized_ref ():
   360   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   361   Changeset: 42457 (ca691a84b81a) PROVISIONALLY MADE TESTS RUN with Unsynchronized.ref
   362   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   363   Date: 2012-08-06 10:38:11 +0200 (11 months)
   364 
   365 
   366   The list below records TODOs while producing an ISAC kernel for 
   367   gdaroczy and jrocnik, wich could NOT be done before all tests are RUNNING
   368   (so to be resumed with Isabelle2013-1):
   369   ############## WNxxxxxx.TODO can be found in sources ##############
   370   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   371   WN111013.TODO: lots of cleanup/removal in test/../Test.thy
   372   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   373   WN111013.TODO: remove concept around "fun init_form", lots of troubles with 
   374   this special case (see) --- why not nxt = Model_Problem here ? ---
   375   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   376   WN111014.TODO calculate_Poly < calculate_Rational < calculate_RootRat, see test/
   377   ... FIRST redesign 
   378   # simplify_* , *_simp_* 
   379   # norm_* 
   380   # calc_* , calculate_*  ... require iteration over all rls ...
   381   ... see --- val rls = calculate_RootRat > calculate_Rational --- CONTINUE !
   382   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   383   WN111014.TODO fun prep_rls | !!!use this function in ruleset' := !!!
   384   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   385   WN120314 changeset a393bb9f5e9f drops root equations.
   386   see test/Tools/isac/Knowledge/rootrateq.sml 
   387   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   388   WN120317.TODO changeset 977788dfed26 dropped rateq:
   389   # test --- repair NO asms from rls RatEq_eliminate --- shows error from 2002
   390   # test --- solve (1/x = 5, x) by me --- and --- x / (x ^ 2 - 6 * x + 9) - ...:    
   391     investigation Check_elementwise stopped due to too much effort finding out,
   392     why Check_elementwise worked in 2002 in spite of the error.
   393   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   394   WN120317.TODO postponed test/../ratinal,ratinal2.sml to joint work with dmeindl 
   395   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   396   WN120317.TODO found by test --- interSteps for Schalk 299a --- that 
   397     NO test with 'interSteps' is checked properly (with exn on changed behaviour)
   398   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   399   WN120317.TODO test --- Matthias Goldgruber 2003 rewrite orders --- has
   400     a newly outcommented test where rewrite_set_ make_polynomial --> NONE
   401   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   402   WN120320.TODO check-improve rlsthmsNOTisac:
   403   DONE make test --- old compute rlsthmsNOTisac by eq_thmI'
   404   DONE compare rlsthmsNOTisac in thms-survey-Isa02-Isa09-2.sml .. Isac.thy 
   405   FOUND 120321: Theory.axioms_of doesnt find LENGTH_CONS etc, thus are in Isab
   406   # mark twice thms (in isac + (later) in Isabelle) in Isac.thy
   407   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   408   WN120320.TODO rlsthmsNOTisac: replace twice thms ^
   409   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   410   WN120320.TODO rlsthmsNOTisac: reconsider design of sym_* thms, see test
   411   --- OLD compute rlsthmsNOTisac by eq_thmID ---: some are in isab, some in isac.
   412   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   413   WN120321.TODO rearrange theories:
   414     Knowledge
   415       :
   416       Atools.thy
   417       ///Descript.thy --> ProgLang
   418       Delete.thy   <--- first_Knowledge_thy (*mv to Atools.thy*)
   419     ProgLang: restructure Build_Isac.thy such that no xmlsrc.thy, ProgLang.thy
   420           Interpret.thy are generated (simplifies xml structure for theories)
   421       Script.thy
   422       Tools.thy
   423       ListC.thy    <--- first_Proglang_thy
   424   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   425   WN120321.TODO reanimate test/../simplify.sml: CAS-command Simplify
   426       EXN "simplify.sml: diff.behav. CAScmd: Simplify (2*a + 3*a)"
   427   broken during work on thy-hierarchy
   428   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   429   WN120321.TODO LAST in IsacScripts + in IsacKnowledge, see
   430   test --- the_hier (get_thes ()) (collect_thydata ())---
   431   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   432   WN120405a.TODO src/../pbl-met-hierarchy.sml: fun pbl2term--> Isac' instead Isac_
   433   !!add mutual crossreferences to ?fun headline??? where the same has to be done:
   434   !!OR BETTER: use only 2 functions for adding/removing "'" to/from thy!!
   435   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   436   WN120409.TODO replace "op mem" (2002) with member (2011) ... 
   437   ... an exercise interesting for beginners !
   438   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   439   WN120411 scanning html representation of newly generated knowledge:
   440   * thy:
   441   ** Theorems: only "Proof of the theorem" (correct!)
   442                and "(c) isac-team (math-autor)"
   443   ** Rulesets: only "Identifier:///"
   444                and "(c) isac-team (math-autor)"
   445   ** IsacKnowledge: link to dependency graph (which needs to be created first)
   446   ** IsacScripts --> ProgramLanguage
   447   *** Tools: Theorems: arity_type_cp, arity_type_nam, ... wegnehmen
   448   
   449   * pbl: OK !?!
   450   * met: OK !?!
   451   * exp: 
   452   ** Z-Transform is missing !!!
   453   ** type-constraints !!!
   454   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   455   WN120417: merging xmldata revealed:
   456   ..............NEWLY generated:........................................
   457   <THEOREMDATA>
   458     <GUH> thy_isab_Fun-thm-o_apply </GUH>
   459     <STRINGLIST>
   460       <STRING> Isabelle </STRING>
   461       <STRING> Fun </STRING>
   462       <STRING> Theorems </STRING>
   463       <STRING> o_apply </STRING>
   464     </STRINGLIST>
   465       <MATHML>
   466         <ISA> (?f o ?g) ?x = ?f (?g ?x) </ISA>
   467       </MATHML>  <PROOF>
   468       <EXTREF>
   469         <TEXT> Proof of the theorem </TEXT>
   470         <URL> http://www.ist.tugraz.at/projects/isac/www/kbase/thy/browser_info/HOL/HOL-Real/Isac/Fun.html </URL>
   471       </EXTREF>
   472     </PROOF>
   473     <EXPLANATIONS> </EXPLANATIONS>
   474     <MATHAUTHORS>
   475       <STRING> Isabelle team, TU Munich </STRING>
   476     </MATHAUTHORS>
   477     <COURSEDESIGNS>
   478     </COURSEDESIGNS>
   479   </THEOREMDATA>
   480   ..............OLD FORMAT:.............................................
   481   <THEOREMDATA>
   482     <GUH> thy_isab_Fun-thm-o_apply </GUH>
   483     <STRINGLIST>
   484       <STRING> Isabelle </STRING>
   485       <STRING> Fun </STRING>
   486       <STRING> Theorems </STRING>
   487       <STRING> o_apply </STRING>
   488     </STRINGLIST>
   489     <THEOREM>
   490       <ID> o_apply </ID>
   491       <MATHML>
   492         <ISA> (?f o ?g) ?x = ?f (?g ?x) </ISA>
   493       </MATHML>
   494     </THEOREM>
   495     <PROOF>
   496       <EXTREF>
   497         <TEXT> Proof of the theorem </TEXT>
   498         <URL> http://www.ist.tugraz.at/projects/isac/www/kbase/thy/browser_info/HOL/HOL-Real/Isac/Fun.html </URL>
   499       </EXTREF>
   500     </PROOF>
   501     <EXPLANATIONS> </EXPLANATIONS>
   502     <MATHAUTHORS>
   503       <STRING> Isabelle team, TU Munich </STRING>
   504     </MATHAUTHORS>
   505     <COURSEDESIGNS>
   506     </COURSEDESIGNS>
   507   </THEOREMDATA>
   508   --------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   509 *}
   510 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   511 text {*
   512   isac development was done between these changesets:
   513   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   514   Changeset: 42519 (1f3b4270363e) meeting dmeindl: added missing files
   515   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   516   Date: 2012-09-24 16:39:30 +0200 (8 months)
   517   :
   518   : isac on Isablle2011
   519   :
   520   Changeset:41897 (355be7f60389) merged isabisac with Isabelle2011
   521   Branch: decompose-isar 
   522   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   523   Date: 2011-02-25 13:04:56 +0100 (2011-02-25)
   524   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   525 *}
   526 
   527 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2009-2 *}
   528 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   529 text {*
   530   In 2009 the update of isac from Isabelle2002 started with switching from CVS to hg.
   531   The update was painful (bridging 7 years of Isabelle development) and cut short 
   532   due to the start of introducing Isabelle's contexts (Mathias Lehnfeld) and
   533   going on to Isabelle2011 although most of the tests did not run.
   534 *}
   535 subsubsection {* Run tests *}
   536 text {*
   537   WN131021 this is broken by installation of Isabelle2011/12/13,
   538   because all these write their binaries to ~/.isabelle/heaps/..
   539 
   540   $ cd /usr/local/isabisac09-2/
   541   $ ./bin/isabelle emacs -l HOL src/Tools/isac/Build_Isac.thy
   542   $ ./bin/isabelle emacs -l Isac src/Tools/isac/Test_Isac.thy
   543   NOT THE RIGHT VERSION.....    test/Tools/isac/Test_Isac.thy !!!
   544 *}
   545 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   546 text {* 
   547   Most tests are broken by the update from Isabelle2002 to Isabelle2009-2.
   548 *}
   549 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   550 text {*
   551   isac development was done between these changesets:
   552   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   553   Changeset: 38115 (940a5feea094) Little improvements of isac-plugin
   554   Branch: decompose-isar 
   555   User: Marco Steger <m.steger@student.tugraz.at>
   556   Date: 2011-02-06 18:30:28 +0100 (2011-02-06)
   557   :
   558   : isac on Isablle2009-2
   559   :
   560   Changeset: 37870 (5100a9c3abf8) created branch isac-from-Isabelle2009-2
   561   Branch: isac-from-Isabelle2009-2 
   562   User: Walther Neuper <neuper@ist.tugraz.at>
   563   Date: 2010-07-21 09:59:35 +0200 (2010-07-21)
   564   ------------------------------------------------------------------------------
   565 *}
   566 
   567 subsection {* isac on Isabelle2002 *}
   568 subsubsection {* Summary of development *}
   569 text {*
   570   From 1999 to 2010 all the basic functionality (except "ctxt" and "error pattern")
   571   of isac's mathematics engine has been implemented.
   572 *}
   573 subsubsection {* Run tests *}
   574 subsubsection {* State of tests *}
   575 text {* 
   576   All tests work on an old notebook (the right PolyML coudn't be upgraded to more
   577   recent Linux versions)
   578 *}
   579 subsubsection {* Changesets of begin and end *}
   580 text {*
   581   Up to the above Mercurial changeset 5100a9c3abf8 isac used CVS;
   582   see https://intra.ist.tugraz.at/hg/isac containing a conversion to Mercurial.
   583 *}
   584 
   585 end
   586 (*========== inhibit exn 130719 Isabelle2013 ===================================
   587 ============ inhibit exn 130719 Isabelle2013 =================================*)
   588 
   589 (*-.-.-.-.-.-isolate response.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.
   590   -.-.-.-.-.-.-isolate response.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.*)
   591